A Fan at Two Speeds

How does the spectrum of the same fan change as its speed increases? Compare two microphone recordings made at the same position and use the laser pulses as an independent reference for blade passage.

Data and test conditions

Download the reference spectra and measurements
Download the fan_tu Dataset manually

Download all five parts to the same folder. On Linux or macOS, run this command in that folder to reconstruct the file for import into GX-TXT.

for n in 01 02 03 04 05; do
  unzip -p "signal-analysis-fan-tu-parte-$n.zip" "fan-tu-parte-$n.bin"
done > fan_tu.gxtxt-dataset.zip

SHA-256 09a28904a8f104a9b04357a46850d14236e0c6a77bdbc60adde1624a396be311

Simon Jekosch and Ennes Sarradj, TU Berlin, Dataset from a microphone arraymeasurement of a rotating fan (2021), CC BY 4.0. The fan has five blades and a diameter of 800 mm. Both runs were recorded on October 23, 2019, in an anechoic chamber, with the array at 1.21 m, the same GRAS 40PL-1 Short CCP microphone, and none of the setup modifications described in the protocol. The reported temperatures are 20.9 and 21.0 °C. Record, DOI and license · Protocol and test table

Fan settingHDF5 fileMicrophoneLaser
40%2019-10-23_10-57-15_767607.h5mic_40trigger_40
100%2019-10-23_11-30-27_924582.h5mic_100trigger_100

The excerpt takes the microphone from zero-based channel 0 and the laser from channel 63 of time_data, from sample 256,000 inclusive to 460,800 exclusive. time_s preserves the original times from 5 s to just under 9 s in each recording. Each series has 204,800 rows sampled at 51,200 Hz. The recordings are independent, and the excerpt covers a run with stable intervals between laser pulses. The HDF5 amplitudes were retained without filtering, gain adjustment or calibration. Values are on the original file’s numerical scale.

Compute both Welch spectra

  1. Import the package into the Session and open Signal Analysis. Choose fan_tu, set mic_40 as the primary signal and time_s as the time coordinate. Leave Paired signal blank and the declared rate at 0.
  2. In Scientific question / method, choose spectral.welch. Set Welch window length to 65536 and Window overlap fraction to 0.5. Click Analyze. Check that the summary shows 204,800 rows, measured sampling and 51,200 Hz.
  3. Set New canonical result Dataset ID to real.fan.40 and click Publish result. Repeat Analyze and Publish with mic_100 and a different ID, for example real.fan.100. Allow several tens of seconds for computation and publication. Open the results as a Plot v4 plot or a canonical table.

The Hamming window is 1.28 s long and advances in steps of 0.64 s. The average uses five complete overlapping segments, covering 196,608 of the 204,800 rows read. With a 65,536-point FFT, the bin spacing is 0.78125 Hz. The actual peak width depends on the window, duration and signal.

Signal Analysis controls configured for Welch PSD on the 40% microphone channel
Welch settings for the 40% channel. Repeat with the same time coordinate and the 100% channel.

Distinguish rotation from blade passage

On each laser channel, find rising crossings of 35, between the resting level and the pulse level. Count one rising edge per revolution and divide 51,200 by the median interval between edges, in samples. Multiply the result by 60 for rpm or by 5 for the blade-passing frequency. The two excerpts contain 49 and 70 rising edges, respectively.

Fan settingMedian intervalRotation rateSpeedExpected blade passagePSD peak
40%4,171.5 samples12.274 Hz736.4 rpm61.369 Hz61.719 Hz
100%2,929 samples17.480 Hz1,048.8 rpm87.402 Hz87.500 Hz

Both peaks are within half a bin of the expected blade-passing frequency. At 100%, another peak is visible at 175 Hz, close to twice the blade-passing fundamental. On the file’s numerical scale, the maximum PSD rises from about 8.62 × 10⁻⁴ to 6.85 × 10⁻². The comparison uses maxima in different bins with the same Welch settings. The values 40% and 100% are fan control settings. The speeds in rpm come from the laser. This comparison covers the two recordings with the fan running. No fan-off background level is available for the selected windows, and the PSD is uncalibrated, so it cannot be read as dB SPL.

Welch spectra with blade-passing peaks near 62 and 88 Hz
The comparison uses the same published Plot v4 data, with a logarithmic vertical scale and the original bins below 475 Hz.

Data, excerpts and derived results are attributed to Simon Jekosch and Ennes Sarradj. CC BY 4.0

File attribution and license