ELEC 07 — Sources, conclusions and tests that could distinguish the mechanisms
Which explanations for the effect of stirring survive all the comparisons? We review the original sources, the GX-TXT results and the measurements that could distinguish the remaining hypotheses.
A bibliography becomes useful when each source’s role is explicit. Some papers define an observable, some supply chemistry or equilibrium, and others show a phenomenon in a different apparatus. Only selected quantities were adopted; an adopted number keeps its original conditions. Retaining a private PDF supports consultation but does not certify parameter transfer.
Sources that directly support the reasoning
| Source | Actual contribution | Transfer limit |
|---|---|---|
| Atrashkevich et al., Breakpoint electrochlorination in ammonia removal: Unveiling the impact of convective mass transfer, Water Research 282 (2025),123732; DOI, Figure3, methods and supplementary S2–S6 | Acquired observations, beaker conditions, summarized rates/SD and distinct controls | Assay is not automatically pure ammonium; aqueous net accumulation is not gross CER |
| Qiang and Adams2004; DOI10.1021/es0347484, equations4–6/18/25–26 | HOCl+NH₃ formation,25°C k/pKa and reference activity convention | Not TNT830 removal; mixture γ is not reactor calibration; no validated formation extrapolation below pH6 |
| Jafvert and Valentine1992; DOI10.1021/es00027a022, TableI,p579–581 | Subsequent chloramine pathways, original M/hour units and catalysis | Not a fully closed elementary network or a unique N₂ yield |
| Gendel and Lahav2012; DOI10.1016/j.electacta.2011.12.092,p209/212/216–219 | Hydrolysis convention, chloramine sequences, UV/DPD and recycling | Different gradients/chloride/electrode; printed Eq25 not implemented; no measured ELEC NCl₃ gas |
| Zhang2018; DOI10.1016/j.watres.2018.08.025,p226–228/Table1 | Resolved original table transcription and limits of incomplete branches | No invented rate law or stoichiometric correction to force executable closure |
| Sander2023; DOI10.5194/acp-23-10901-2023,definitions/TableA1 | Neutral-species c/p Henry convention, temperature conventions and primary references | No reactor K_La; equilibrium is not a transport rate |
Consultable source notes retain page/equation provenance: chlorine/pH conventions, chloramination kinetics, and Zhang original table. Not every retained paper was parameter-mined for every possible purpose. Documented non-adoption and an unassessed specific use are different states.
Five ammonia-transfer originals: what was and was not adopted
All five were retained canonically with RAW copies in the same ELEC scientific Session. They are contextual and convention sources, not new reactor experiments. Their condition-specific coefficients were not adopted as ELEC parameters.
| Original | Purpose/apparatus | Use and non-adoption |
|---|---|---|
| Clegg and Brimblecombe1989, Solubility of Ammonia in Pure Aqueous and Multicomponent Solutions; DOI10.1021/j100357a041,Eq3/TableI/Eqs17–18,p7242–7243 | Solubility, temperature and electrolyte interactions | Molality/pressure and neutral activity distinctions adopted; no reactor numerical Henry constant or Pitzer implementation |
| Degermenci2022, Air stripping of ammonia using a gas-liquid contactor; DOI10.5505/pajes.2021.19540,p864–865 | Forced-air contactor varying pH,temperature,airflow and dose | Apparent pool-decay KLa is not automatically intrinsic neutral-NH₃ transfer. The reported0.0462min⁻¹ example at pH11/55°C/20Lmin⁻¹/100mgL⁻¹ belongs to that source; it is not asserted to be its unique maximum or an ELEC value |
| Agustin Corruchaga, Oriol Casal, Adriana Palacios and Joaquim Casal2022, Influence of wind speed and ammonia concentration on its evaporation rate from aqueous solution spills; DOI10.1016/j.jlp.2022.104750 | Concentrated free-surface spills,wind,cooling and water condensation | Useful distinction of thermal/gas balances; m/s coefficients and exposed area are not a stirred-cell KLa |
| Hossini, Rezaee, Ayati and Mahvi2016, Optimizing ammonia volatilization by air stripping from aquatic solutions using RSM; DOI10.1080/19443994.2015.1046946 | Forced stripping and empirical optimization of pH,dose and air | Original time/concentration ambiguities retained; apparent first-order decay is not automatically a liquid-film coefficient or fixed neutral fraction |
| Hasar et al.2009, Stripping/flocculation/membrane bioreactor/reverse osmosis treatment of municipal landfill leachate; DOI10.1016/j.jhazmat.2009.06.003 | Multistage leachate treatment | Context for removal/recovery; different matrix/processes and flow/protocol inconsistencies prevent ready transfer to ELEC electrochemistry |
Clegg is no longer a missing original; earlier missing-source notes are historical snapshots. Optional unavailable originals remain Connick and Chia, The Hydrolysis of Chlorine and its Variation with Temperature, JACS81(1959),1280–1284, DOI10.1021/ja01515a004; Aieta and Roberts, Henry constant of molecular chlorine in aqueous solution, JCED31(1986),51–53, DOI10.1021/je00043a017; and Whitney and Vivian, Solubility of Chlorine in Water, IEC33(1941),741–744, DOI10.1021/ie50378a014. Their full texts were not read and no missing coefficients were invented. The Whitney paper is an alternative source, not an obligatory third experiment.
Saguinsin and Morris’s1975 chapter The chemistry of aqueous nitrogen trichloride, in J.D.Johnson(ed.), Disinfection: Water and Wastewater,Chapter14,p277–299,ISBN9780250400423, remains an optional unavailable primary text for acidic trichloramine kinetics. A secondary relative-rate statement is not promoted to a measured absolute law.
These gaps limit specific refinement of temperature, salinity, hydrolysis and acidic rates. They do not prohibit clearly attributed Sander-reference exploratory scenarios or a clean-gas prescribed-KLa calculation that does not resolve gas-film pressure. No such scenario is called a measurement.
Romano: a structural reference, not a reproduced model
Romano, Ortiz and Urtiaga’s Comprehensive kinetics of electrochemically assisted ammonia removal in marine aquaculture recirculating systems, J.Electroanal.Chem.897(2021),115619, DOI10.1016/j.jelechem.2021.115619, combines separately calibrated chlorine generation, chloramine chemistry and cell/tank balances. It supports distinguishing source calibration from nitrogen inference and retaining chloramine inventories instead of treating every chlorine demand as immediate assay-N removal.
Its Ti/RuO₂ anode/Ti cathode,0.2cm channel,6.5L/min recirculation,2L tank at22°C and28.4gNaCl/L differ from the stirred200mL Ti/IrO₂ experiment. TAN is NH₃+NH₄⁺, not automatically the chloramine-inclusive response declared for ELEC. Printed source-local/whole-system distinctions, a transport-sign inconsistency in Eq12, and unresolved intermediate/product closure prevent a blind table-to-code transfer. No Romano coefficient, simulation or validation was adopted. Reviewed source interpretation.
The new Romano original, a12-page Atrashkevich publisher edition and a byte-distinct Zhang PDF are canonically retained with RAW copies. The Zhang text matches the existing study rather than adding an independent experiment. Source readability/reopen and final Portable custody have separate records; publisher PDFs are not included in this public WordPress asset package.
Controls that resist a simple mechanism story
In the divided closed cell,150mM electrolyte and200mL per compartment, the reported aqueous source decreases from6.61 to4.6mgCl₂/L/min between0 and1300rpm. Recovered liquid and gas chlorine both decrease while their shares remain approximately76%/24%. Main-manuscript Figure6c/lines497–505 reports recovered/measured liquid-plus-gas chlorine yield changing from64.0±2.0% to44.0±3.0%, not independently established gross CER. The authors give p=0.061 for0 versus100rpm, so that difference is not declared significant at0.05. These are cited source results, not new calculations from supplementary tables.
The trend with a separated cathode and gas recovery challenges an exclusively cathodic account to address separation/crossover. It is not explained simply by relocating a fixed recovered inventory from liquid to gas. The authors propose acidic-interface and CER–OER competition reasoning; our constraints do not independently identify that hypothesis. Closed-cell gas recovery after Ar purging and NaOH capture is not an NH₃/NCl₃ measurement, and different spike/perchlorate controls do not supply interchangeable κ values.
Scientific balance at the freeze
Completed native work includes N calibrations, four S2-h calibrations, three common-h controls, six exact-time fixed chlorine transfers and25 current-bound ratios. Partial nitrogen-present chlorine is free3+total1 at100rpm, with declared exclusions and unknown bars/replicates. Two ten-row bulk-pH traces and p0038 are available. Native algebra produced nine initial-pH components, ideal NH₃ fraction and three conditional chlorine fractions on actual nitrogen-present pH rows.
Generic0.2.5 completed0/100rpm operational networks,61/151 retained times and nine tables each. Analytical verification of existing native arrays found maximum absolute A/B errors about1.3531×10⁻¹³/2.0304×10⁻¹³mol/m³ at0rpm and2.528799×10⁻¹⁴/3.690279×10⁻¹⁴mol/m³ at100rpm. This verifies numerical execution, not physical mechanism. No dedicated generic-network or fraction plot is claimed. The combined-chlorine versus remaining-N test, clipped NH₃ exposure/K threshold and pH-forced loss candidate were not executed; no gas flux,KLa or CFD result is reported.
Private versions are documented separately from planned P013. Generic0.2.6 is installed but its forcing use is unqualified; Numeric1.65.3 is retained uninstalled. Reproducibility on P013 requires its eventual availability and verification; it cannot be advertised as a released dependency today.
The outcome is not one identified mechanism. Quantitative conditional constraints limit restrictive common-source/common-loss closures, while effective fitted parameters do not become elementary kinetics. Speciation, recovery, products and transfer cannot be replaced by another free coefficient fitted to the same sparse nitrogen curve. Keeping results, assumptions and unresolved questions separate is the central scientific deliverable.
Datasets
Current-ceiling scalar/context · S2 calibrations and common-h controls · Current-bound ratios · Six fixed-parameter transfers · Free/total deficits · Nine initial-pH components · Operational0rpm network: nine outputs · Operational100rpm network: nine outputs · Two acquired pH traces · Ideal NH₃ fraction · Three conditional chlorine fractions · Original assay-N centres · Partial nitrogen-present chlorine · Original nitrogen-free controls
Digitized Figure 3 observations (12 CSV files in a ZIP archive) · Native model and constraint results (27 CSV files in a ZIP archive)
Related reading on Giux-Lab
Turbulence and electrical resistance in single-phase electrolytes · Electric field line distortion in electrochemistry.
Other steps of this project
- ELEC 02 — Model hierarchy: effective kinetics, transfer and identifiability
- ELEC 03 — From fits to constraints: what does the chlorine balance reveal?
- ELEC 01 — What does the experiment measure? Nitrogen, chlorine and pH
- ELEC 04 — Kinetics, speciation and transport: from local reaction to reactor response
- ELEC 06 — Where the numbers came from: GX-TXT, GNU Octave and reproducibility
- ELEC 05 — Gas loss, chloramines and the proton balance