13. Complementary sources and scope of the research

The complementary references indicate where to find the measurements, models and contemporary accounts that support the review. For works consulted only through an abstract, the bibliographic details or a contemporary notice, the level of access is given, as it is useful for interpreting the result.

Handbooks, articles and archive copies

YearDocumentEvidence and access
1931Nottingham, publisher’s identifierFull text cited in the chapter on the predecessors.
1940Harrison, Ionization Time of ThyratronsAbstract of the publication and manuscript held at Caltech. Page 16 examines the definition of overvoltage.
1946Chance, Note on the Ionization and Deionization Times of Gas-filled ThyratronsThe IRE abstract of August 1946, p. 620, gives values and measurement conditions for the G.T.1C. Page 16 specifies the data taken from the abstract.
1947Romanowitz, Measurements, Analysis, and Statistical Nature of Deionization Time in a Mercury Vapor ThyratronUniversity of Kentucky bulletin, December 1947. An RCA citation gives vol. 2, no. 2. The numbering should be checked on the title page.
1948Glasoe and Lebacqz, Pulse GeneratorsScan of the monograph, vol. 5 of the MIT Radiation Laboratory Series.
1949Knight, Hot-Cathode Thyratrons: Practical Studies of CharacteristicsContemporary notice. Proceedings IEE, part III, 96(43), 361–378, with discussion on pp. 379–381.
1949Verzuh, Technical Report 101Text copy of the MIT report on deionization time measurements.
1950Malter and Johnson, Studies of Thyratron BehaviorScan of RCA Review, vol. 11, p. 165 ff.
1951Malter and Boyd, The Trigger-Grid ThyratronScan of Proceedings of the IRE, 39(6), 636–643.
1954Brooker and Ware, Cheater Circuits for the Testing of Thyratrons, part IScan of the journal, p. 43 ff. Documents the measurement before firing.
1956Appel and Fünfer, Firing Delay and Build-Up Time of the Discharge in the ThyratronZ. angew. Phys. 8(7), 322–327. The linked source is the contemporary abstract service. The original text has yet to be checked.
1958Schure, Gas TubesReproduction of the chapter with figure 18 and the 884–2D21 comparison.
1959Adati and Sawa, pulse control of the 2D21 thyratronOriginal text and figures 4–7. Effect of the initial bias and of the interval between pulses on the sensitivity of the tube. Discussed in detail on page 17.
1994Barnes and Wait, EPAC 1994Accessible proceedings. They show the use of PSpice for the circuit response to a multigap transient.
Technical documentationPhilips, Thyratrons for Modern IndustryChapter 7 of the handbook documents the PL2D21, preheating and the conditions for measuring control ratios. See the reading on page 14.
MacromodelZabb, Thyratron.zipArchive given by the author for the .CIR and .TSM files.

Three recent experiments on delay, spread and interruption

Korolev and coworkers (2018) study a cold-cathode TPI1-10k/50 in deuterium. An auxiliary discharge keeps the device ready to fire. The current–voltage characteristic of figure 4 and the oscillograms of figures 5 and 6 link the initial state of the auxiliary discharge to the delay of the main discharge. In the tests at about 40 kV the authors report an overall delay of about 100 ns and a spread within 15 ns. The result documents a physical source of variability that would be lost by assigning the device a fixed delay. Korolev et al., Plasma Physics Reports 44, 110–117.

Kim and coworkers (2023) observe an L4888. They define the delay from the generator command to the start of the anode current rise and characterize both the trigger supply and those of the cathode and reservoir heaters. Figure 11 shows the waveforms and figure 12 expresses the jitter as a standard deviation as a function of trigger energy. The value of 152 ps RMS concerns the system tested under the reported conditions. Comparing it directly with Korolev’s 15 ns would confuse devices, time references and statistical definitions. Kim et al., IEEE Transactions on Plasma Science, 2023.

Kruglov and coworkers (2021) consider current interruption in a device with a sector-shaped aperture in the shield, connected to an inductive store. In figure 5 they superimpose on the voltage and current waveforms the functions used to approximate them. The time integral of the voltage–current product makes it possible to distinguish the energy dissipated during conduction from that dissipated during opening. Under the conditions studied, the relative weight of the two changes with the pulse amplitude. It is an example of what can be obtained from two synchronized traces. A measurement of grid recovery, on the other hand, also requires establishing when, and with what bias, the tube can withstand the anode voltage again. Kruglov et al., MECO 2021, figures 4–6.

The pulse-forming network in the study by Han and coworkers

Han and coworkers (2023) start from the waveform that must reach the load. They represent the trapezoidal pulse by harmonic components and compare two ways of realizing a third-order pulse-forming network (PFN). They transform a series-resonant network into an antiresonant one to reduce the required inductance value and the spread of component values. Figures 8–11 make it possible to follow the step from the schematics to the simulation results. Figure 14 compares the waveform before and after optimization.

The authors indicate verification on physical components as a later development. The agreement reported concerns the waveforms calculated for the two networks. In the bibliographic comparison this work illustrates a problem different from identifying the tube. An external network can accurately reproduce a pulse at the load even when the grid current and the threshold of the individual thyratron remain to be measured. Han et al., Tehnički vjesnik 30 (2023), 2009–2017.

Searches that set the boundaries of the result

The survey searched separately for grid current with the anode conducting, current before firing, characteristics at variable G2 and circuit models. To widen coverage, the 2050, 884, 885, 3D21/3D22, EN91 and PL2D21 were considered, as well as the designations CV797 and 5727 as leads to be checked in the documents of the individual manufacturers. The experimental families, local laws and dynamic models found are described in the previous pages.

The search in handbooks, articles, patents and SPICE archives returned numerous application circuits. In the corpus examined, the only macromodel directly documented as compatible with the 2D21 is Zabb’s. For the 885 type, characteristics and applications emerged, while a dedicated SPICE model has yet to be documented. The search targeted at Verilog-A did not find a verifiable model specific to the 2D21. These outcomes set the limits of the bibliographic coverage and can be updated with new full texts or model archives.

Zabb’s netlist documents a concrete circuit choice. Adati and Sawa’s measurements offer an independent check for repeated firing of the 2D21. The most significant open questions are the exact form of French’s criterion, the mathematical equivalence with any precedents and the extension of the quantitative tests to the manufacturer’s three families. The matrix on page 11 specifies which text or data is needed for each comparison.

How to find the illustrations in the scans

SourceReference to look forWhat can be checked
Zenith, operating and service manualCover and plate on p. 9Photograph of the receiver and actual designations of the three tubes on the chassis.
Schure, Gas TubesFigs. 18 and 27, pp. 38 and 52884/2D21 comparison and RCA internal construction.
Sylvania 2D21Pages 4 and 5 of the data sheetAC operating bands and currents before conduction.
Mullard, EN91Printed p. 43, page 47 of the PDFGraphs 117, 118 and 119 on the same sheet.
RCA AN-131Fig. 1 on p. 2 and final errata sheetTimer and correction of the references in the text of the note.
Malter and JohnsonPart I, figs. 3–6, pp. 170–171Oscillograms and reconstruction of the ion current.
Olmstead and RothRCA Review 18 (2), 272–284, June 1957Test bench, firing and recovery curves measured on the 2D21.
Museums VictoriaCollection ST 28272Photo of the RCA tube, scale and image license.

#2D21 #characteristic curves #electron tube #Flash-Matic #GE datasheet #General Electric #grid current #SPICE #thyratron #vacuum tubes

Other steps of this project